Geocities proves websites really are like sharks: if you stop moving, you die. A call to keep innovating.

It is staggering that Yahoo has moved to close Geocities -- a site with a decade worth of content. An Internet treasure (... of sorts.) And it's STILL being used by over 10 million people monthly. It's a top 100 site, according to compete.com.

Look at Google Sites, Google's website offering that has been around for a fraction of the time. They're only about 1/3rd the traffic of Geocities... but they're closing fast. Geocities has been taking a beating.

Why? For a completely reversible reason. Geocities has remained static and unchanging for years and years... and web software is like a shark. You stop moving and you die. I can only speculate about the team that got stuck in maintenance mode here.

There is an oft-repeated meme with startups around how it is staffed with commandos, infantry, or police. Commandos are the founders -- they go in guns blazing and destroy everything they see. But there aren't enough commandos, and when the front is breached, they make way for the infantry. They actually score the victory, building up upon the success of the commandos. Most mid-stage startups are waging battle at this level. And then... the police come in. They're bumbling, but the market is already owned, so they can eat donuts and get fat.

What if Yahoo had brought in a new set of commandos? Real gunners. Probably akin to what MySpace has done recently with their radical reorg. I can think of a dozen smart crack commando web startups out there that would chomp at the bit to save an Internet treasure like Geocities. Build new features, update the software to the 21st century, and get the ball rolling again. Zap that shark with a defibrilator and get it swimming again.

You should follow me on twitter here.

Loading mentions Retweet
Posted 27 days ago

8 comments

Oct 27, 2009
Becky said...
I wonder why they chose this move, instead of improving it. Guess it's all about money in the end... It's with nostalgia I think of Geocities ... had an account there before Yahoo bought it.

I used to like Yahoo. Can't say I do anymore..

Oct 27, 2009
Suz E. said...
Yahoo has done this with everything they offer that is free I think. I think it's a mistake. I have mail that I don't use because AT&T is my server but I will never use anything from Yahoo again. I don't even like their search. They have completely destroyed their credibility and trust with people who have used their services for years. I'm a Google girl all the way. I hope they don't go the way of Yahoo some day.
Oct 27, 2009
kobi hsu said...
I'm going to guess that Yahoo /forced/ it to be in maintenance mode, and made a deliberate decision to kill it shortly after they purchased it, first by neglect... and then, when that didn't work, by pulling the plug. AOL did the same thing with compuserv and netscape. Corporate thinking frequently is that once you've got the users you can just kill the brand, because all other brands are competition. Then they're surprised when they eyeballs they were counting on leave.
Oct 27, 2009
Becky said...
Guess I lost it somehow, for Yahoo, during that stupidity about Y360. They should have just killed it right away.

I am now a Google person all the way ... the only thing that scares me is that Yahoo owns Flickr.

Oct 27, 2009
Alex Schleber said...
Those are two great metaphors. I especially like the "Commandos, Infantry, Police" one, I'll use this from now on in some of my coaching client discussions on innovation and SPEED.

Yahoo has been fumbling the ball on social media for years. It's really incredible, on paper they had and still have all of the ingredients for the mother of all social networks, but they've done next to nothing.

They bought delicious and flickr, and that was it. No real blogging product, micro or otherwise, no integration, nothing. Bought MyBlogLog and did next to nothing with it... sigh.

Nov 02, 2009
Ian May said...
Isn't some of it snobbery too? Even if Geocities hadn't closed, or even if MySpace really invents itself, aren't there a size-able amount of people out there, who will simply say that they are not going to stoop that low to use it?

Much like it wouldn't matter if Microsoft bought out an OS that really was superior to Apple's or Linux, there will alwasy be those that refuse to go that way?

Nov 02, 2009
Becky said...
I think you definitely have a point there, and it was very well put!

Nov 02, 2009
Garry Tan said...
Ian -- There's something to be said for the fact that Geocities was a brand that went stale and became associated with lack of savvy. But maybe with the right repositioning you can salvage something.

Websites have remarkable inertia -- big sites get big and stay big. It's comparatively hard to get big. So when you've got a lot of users, it makes sense to protect what you've got by continuing to innovate and break ground on new products and services.

Leave a comment...

 
To leave a comment on this posterous, please login by clicking one of the following.
Posterous-login     Connect     twitter